Call or text, either is fine519-573-6082
Open the Waterloo Region Guide

Home Sellers

What if our property already sat on the market with another agent?

By Michelle McPheePublished Updated 4 min read
A tidy front entrance of a home prepared for a fresh listing in Waterloo Region

A listing that sat with another agent is a reason to reset, not a reason to panic. Here is what to rethink before you list again.

On this page
  1. Why a stalled listing feels so discouraging
  2. Separate the property from the listing
  3. What one seller’s experience shows
  4. Questions to ask before you list again
  5. A starting point for your review
  6. Communication matters as much as strategy
  7. A practical way to restart

Why a stalled listing feels so discouraging

When your property sits on the market for months without serious interest, it is easy to wonder whether it will ever sell. The showings slow down, the feedback feels vague, and each week without an offer makes the next one harder to face.

A stalled listing is common, and it rarely means the property cannot sell. More often it means something about the listing, the price, the presentation, or the communication did not connect with the buyers who were looking.

The good news is that most of those things can be reviewed and changed. This article covers what to look at before you list again.

Separate the property from the listing

Start by pulling apart two questions that often get tangled together. The first is about the property itself: its location, condition, layout, and what it offers. The second is about the listing: the price, the photos, the description, the timing, and how it was presented.

You cannot easily change the first question. You can change almost everything about the second. A fresh look at the listing is usually where the most useful changes are found.

Be honest with yourself about both. Some properties, like vacant land or homes that need work, appeal to a narrower group of buyers. That does not make them unsellable, but it does change how the listing needs to reach the right people.

What one seller’s experience shows

Every re-listing is different, and past results are not a forecast for your property. Still, it can help to see how a reset played out for someone in a similar spot.

One client described a vacant property that had been listed with a previous agent for years without serious offers. They wrote: “We had a vacant piece of property and a previous agent had 5 years to sell it and we did not receive any serious offers. Within a month Michelle brought us 2 serious offers.”

That is one story, not a promise. What it does show is that a stalled listing is worth a genuine second look, rather than simply waiting longer or dropping the price without a plan.

Questions to ask before you list again

Before you sign a new listing agreement, gather answers to a few practical questions:

  • What feedback came back from the showings you did have?
  • How did the original price compare with recent sales of similar properties?
  • Did the photos and description show the property at its best?
  • How often were you updated, and did you understand what was happening?

If you do not have clear answers to these, that alone tells you something. A re-listing should start with a clearer picture than the first attempt had.

A starting point for your review

This table is a way to organize the conversation, not a checklist of guaranteed fixes. Use it to spot where the first listing may have missed.

AreaWhat to reviewQuestions to ask
PriceHow it compared with recent salesWas it set for today’s market or an older one?
PhotosLighting, angles, and first impressionsWould a buyer stop scrolling on the first image?
DescriptionWhat the listing said and left outDoes it explain who the property suits?
ConditionRepairs and presentationWhat would a buyer notice first in person?
UpdatesHow often you heard from your agentDid you know what buyers were saying?

Pricing and condition questions depend on current comparable sales and the property itself, so confirm them with a licensed professional before you decide.

Communication matters as much as strategy

Many sellers coming off a stalled listing say the hardest part was not knowing what was happening. Weeks would pass without clear feedback, and it was hard to tell whether anything was working.

Before you list again, agree on how often you will hear from your agent, what you will hear about, and how showing feedback will be shared. Clear updates will not sell a property on their own, but they help you make better decisions along the way.

A practical way to restart

When you are ready to talk about a re-listing, it helps to bring a few things to the first conversation:

  • The dates and price history of the previous listing
  • Any showing feedback you received
  • Repairs or changes you have made since, or are willing to make
  • Your timeline and how much flexibility you have

No agent can guarantee offers, a sale price, or days on market. What a fresh start can give you is a clearer plan, an honest review of what did not work, and regular communication while you try again.

This article is educational and reflects publicly available information. It is not legal, tax, or lending advice. Confirm contract and closing questions with a real estate lawyer, financing with a licensed lender, and current listings and pricing with a licensed Ontario real estate professional.

Written by

Michelle McPhee

Michelle McPhee, Broker, RE/MAX Solid Gold Realty (II) Ltd., Brokerage

Home Sellers

How should sellers think about pricing and preparation before photos in KW?

Ask Michelle a Question